Do you remember Vanessa Carlton? Most of us know her as the one who introduced us to ”A Thousand Miles,” a peppy, pretty, popular, pop song (say that three times fast), back in 2002. It was a strong single, followed by “Ordinary Day.” I attended her concert in Boston and was thoroughly delighted by the performance, albeit she had a cough and struggled somewhat. I bought her second album Harmonium, and I even purchased her piano books so I could recreate her beautiful medleys on my own. Back in October, when I heard she had a new album out, I immediately purchased it and allowed the music to fill my room. Unfortunately, I was disappointed.
It seems that many artists today are trying to create music that sets them apart from the rest of the musicians. While it is a valiant effort, I wish the musicians would be reminded not to compromise their own talent for their new diversity. Heroes and Thieves is nothing more than a mediocre attempt at something new. Some parts of the album really shine, a perfect mixture of voice and harmony, like the title-song “Heroes and Thieves.” Yet, the majority of the album feels like it’s just reaching, hoping it passes for something better than it is. Carlton has never sounded comfortable in the range she sets herself up for, but I’ve let that slide because the melodies are great… This time the melodies were just “okay” and, honestly, sometimes her voice becomes downright painful (“My Best” and “Home”).
If you’re not familiar with Carlton, I’d definitely recommend that you check out her website. The graphics are very unique and intriguing, but you also will get a chance to listen to some clips to get a taste of her music. If you like it, I’d say that her first two albums, Be Not Nobody and Harmonium are the safe options to buy. Only buy Heroes and Thieves if you’re still in love, but be warned, it could break your heart.
